CAPTAIN SIM FORUM
767 Captain (FSX) >> 767 Captain (FSX) >> Spoilers/Air Brakes
https://www.captainsim.org/forum/csf.pl?num=1327655259

Message started by wb2002 on Jan 27th, 2012 at 9:07am

Title: Spoilers/Air Brakes
Post by wb2002 on Jan 27th, 2012 at 9:07am
Whenever I attempt to slow the plane down quickly, engaging the spoilers full, have very little effect. Is this normal or could be fixed?

Title: Re: Spoilers/Air Brakes
Post by CloudSurferIII on Jan 27th, 2012 at 7:00pm
When deploying speedbrakes with default FSX planes you can see the speed drops very fast, the plane goes nose-up and looses stability like it's stalling. You have to use them like 3 or 4 seconds to already get your desired speed. It's not realist at all.

CS 767 is realist on that point. Like in real aircraft, speedbrakes take a little time to slow down the plane, specially if you go heavy.

Title: Re: Spoilers/Air Brakes
Post by wb2002 on Jan 27th, 2012 at 9:19pm

R. Aranda S. wrote on Jan 27th, 2012 at 7:00pm:


CS 767 is realist on that point. Like in real aircraft, speedbrakes take a little time to slow down the plane, specially if you go heavy.


Since I have not piloted a real 737 or 767, I'll take your word for this. I do know from a passenger point of view that the effect of deploying the speed brake is felt significantly and makes quite a bit of noise. As I mentioned, the effect on the CS767-300 is negligible. or I am doing something wrong.

Title: Re: Spoilers/Air Brakes
Post by Morten on Jan 28th, 2012 at 12:12am
What is your approximate approach speed, just before flare out..?

Title: Re: Spoilers/Air Brakes
Post by wb2002 on Jan 28th, 2012 at 6:28am

Morten wrote on Jan 28th, 2012 at 12:12am:
What is your approximate approach speed, just before flare out..?


Usually around 130-145.

On landings I don't use speedbrakes to slow plane - I use them (now called spoilers) to destroy wing lift after touchdown. I use speedbrakes sometimes while trying to descend quickly and not pick up speed while doing it.

Title: Re: Spoilers/Air Brakes
Post by CloudSurferIII on Jan 29th, 2012 at 2:52am

wb2002 wrote on Jan 28th, 2012 at 6:28am:

On landings I don't use speedbrakes to slow plane - I use them (now called spoilers) to destroy wing lift after touchdown. I use speedbrakes sometimes while trying to descend quickly and not pick up speed while doing it.


There is an airline and/or FAA thing which sets a minimum altitude for speedbrake mid-air deploy. You shouldn't use them below a few thousand feet from the ground, and that's pushing it. Your speed may drop close to stall, specially if you have already selected a flap setting.

Look, there is a maneuver for rapid descending spin-push-spin-pull, if you have a bit trouble going down at time and holding your desired speed. It's designed to descend quickly and smoothly without 360šs or agressive dives.
Terrain may be higher than 9,000 ft and your autopilot with autothrottle must be properly engaged to this procedure.
-Spin: spin the MCP altitude to your setting alt.
-Push: push FL CH.
-Spin: spin the airspeed up to above Mmo(Mach maximum operating)/Vmo(Maximum operating speed). Initially spin it above and then adjust it to less once the descent is established. Do not overspeed.
-Pull: pull the speedbrake lever.

From the FL300+ club, predict your dive and keep and eye on the speed so you may have full control when you begin approaching your destination.

Rigo.

Title: Re: Spoilers/Air Brakes
Post by wb2002 on Jan 29th, 2012 at 5:27am
All said, I understand. I am comparing the spoiler affect of this A/C with all the others I have PMDG747, Aerosim 747 & 777, Feelthere ERJ145, Eaglesoft CitationX, CLS MD81/82, Default 747 & 737, and others. I have been on several real flights where I have observed the extending of airbrakes at high altitudes. I always make it a point to observe wing control services. Whether it is a regulated thing or not - I have no idea. What I do know is that it is often used on flights that I have been on.

I was interested in if it was possible to make an adjustment to the effectiveness in the A/C configuration file.

Title: Re: Spoilers/Air Brakes
Post by LOU on Feb 10th, 2012 at 9:00pm
wb2002,

The speed brakes on the 767/757 are less effective than the 727. The speed you are flying at the time of deployment also had some bearing.
Above 250 knots the spoilers tend to "blow down" or be less effective since the angle of the deployment is less than at lower speed. The area of the speed brake is also smaller than the 727 which also has some blow down.

Try this:

At cruise altitude (FL300) and at high speed ( M.80 ) with the autopilot on, give this a try.

First just close the throttles and see the speed bleed from say M.80 to M.75. Time it.

Next, do the same, but after you close the throttles, deploy the speed brakes and time it as well.

Now in lower altitude fly the plane at 250 knots, 10,000 on the autopilot. Do the same test as above. First just close the throttles then use the brakes and see the difference.

BTW, you can use the speed brakes with any flap setting something that is verboten in the 727. You can also use the speed brakes on approach if needed, but keep an eye on the speed!

The 757/767 is a very clean plane and hard to slow down. The 757 being a bit harder than the 767. It takes some planning to make crossing altitudes in both planes. You can either use the default / key to deploy or in VC, you can grab the handle and use just small amounts or anything in between. I would always try to sneak on the brakes so as not to disturb the passengers since there will be some vibration with deployment.

Let me know what you discover in this test.

I find they work pretty much as they do in the RW.

Lou

Title: Re: Spoilers/Air Brakes
Post by fuzzy11 on Mar 2nd, 2012 at 8:49pm
I have the Go-Flight Throttle Quadrant and you can be very exact how much you want hanging out or up, in this case.  It's like trim adjustment, but only better.

If you have extra throttles, you could probably map spoilers to them.

CAPTAIN SIM FORUM » Powered by YaBB 2.6.0!
YaBB Forum Software © 2000-2024. All Rights Reserved.